Column on Why Rip Off the Rich?

Why Rip Off The Rich?

Tibor R. Machan

This
fracas about letting the Bush tax cut expire for those making more than
the arbitrary amount of $250K per year is bizarre.  Never mind for now
that the entire system of taxation in a
bona fide
free country is criminal–not different, in principle, from a system of
serfdom or involuntary servitude.  (Taxation had its place in the same
systems that were home to these other types of bondage!) But this
unrestrained hatred for those who earn more than $250K is rank bigotry,
not different from racial, gender and ethnic prejudice at heart.  

Well,
yes there is a difference, since when men and women become wealthy,
this isn’t unavoidable as when they are black or women or from a given
background into which they were born.  But neither is becoming wealthy
something for which anyone ought to be blamed and punished.  

It
is, after all, no longer the case that behind every great fortune there
must be a great crime.  That used to be generally true enough when
wealth was obtained primarily
via
conquest, looting, and robbery perpetrated by armies and navies.  One
of the great discoveries of Adam Smith, the father of modern economic
science, is that wealth is much more efficiently created without such
methods, by protecting the equal liberty of everyone to produce and
trade.  Because we are often so radically different from one another, we
can easily find opportunities to gain from others while they are also
gaining from us.  This is one of the benefits of specialization.
 Understanding this much should be sufficient to reject the notion that
anyone needs to be put in servitude to other people so that these others
can find what they need and want.  A genuine, unbriddled free market
place makes that possible, one in which the government with its monopoly
on physical force does not try to cherry pick who gets what and how
much and when.

Apart,
however, of the irrationality of interfering in people’s freedom of
production and exchange, there is in this debate about extending the
Bush tax cuts to those who make more than $250K a viciousness that
should be entirely unwelcome among civilized men and women.  This
enviousness that many people harbor and which is then taken advantage of
by so many politicians–and fueled by their academic instigators such
as
The New York Times
columnist and Princeton University economist Paul Krugman–is
neanderthal, barbaric, totally unbecoming of people who live in a
complex society and who have only the faintest idea of how others earn
their resources.  To have cultivated this envy toward those who are
economically better off is really no different from cultivating it
toward those who have superior talents or other assets in their lives,
such as good health and good looks.  To pick on such people is totally
unjust and pointless.

Some,
of course, try to peddle the notion that the very rich really owe it
all to society–which is to say, to politicians and law enforcement–as
if it were the referees at a game who scored points!  But that is a
fabrication and rationalization aimed to sooth one’s guilty conscience
for harboring the envy of those who happen to be better off.  Nothing
good can come from it and a lot of ill will and needless acrimony is
fostered by it all.

We
have a very fine model for understanding economic differences among
people in the field of competitive athletics.  Sportsmanship is part of
it, whereby competitors at all the different levels of achievement and
skill live in harmony instead of hating one another and insisting on
placing extra burdens on the successful.  (Where there is a policy of
handicapping it usually serves the purpose of making the sport more
appealing to spectators and has nothing to do with equalization!)

I
suggest we get rid of this attitude of rich bashing once and for all
and shame those who refuse to do so instead of exploiting their attitude
for political purposes.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s