Column on Obama’s Likely Supreme Court Choice

Obama’s Supreme Court Plans

Tibor R. Machan

This is just a rumor but it seems like President Obama will attempt to
place Harvard University Law Professor Cass Sunstein on the U. S. Supreme
Court. This idea has been aired on the Internet at The Washington
Independent web site. For the time being Sunstein has been tapped to head
the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs but, as the site reports,
“Sunstein has also been mentioned as a potential Supreme Court pick under
Obama, although a position in the administration might reduce the
likelihood that he’ll move to the bench.”

This is an ominous prospect, to say the least, given that Professor
Sunstein has been a constant critic of a prominent element of the American
legal tradition, namely, the institution of the right to private property.
The Fifth Amendment to the U. S. Constitution mentions this right
explicitly when it states that “nor shall private property be taken for
public use without just compensation.” Indeed, the only such taking that
is permitted is “for public use,” which is to say, strictly speaking, for
a use of the entire citizenry–for example, a military based, a court
house, or a police station. These are the kind of facilities that qualify
as public ones since their function is to serve the entire public, not
certain special or private purposes.

The reason the July 2005 U. S. Supreme Court ruling in Kelo v. City of
New London, CT., was such a departure from the U. S. Constitution is that
it sanctioned the taking of private property of private use–the City was
going to transfer Kelo’s property to some private industry that would pay
higher taxes. (Nothing has been developed on that property so far, by the

Professor Sunstein believes, judging by the book he coauthored with
Stephen Holmes, Cost of Rights: Why Liberty Depends on Taxes (W.W. Norton,
2006), that the public at large–meaning the government–owns all the
wealth in the country and taxation is merely its way of leaving some of
that wealth for private citizens to use as they see fit–that is to say,
whatever remains in their hands once the public via government has assumed
control of the wealth it supposedly owns.

This is a thoroughly reactionary view of property, given that a basic
characteristic of the regime overthrown by the American Revolution as that
it owned the country. In a feudal system the government–king, tsar,
pharaoh, or some such ruler–owns the entire country, even its citizenry
or, rather, subjects! The American Revolution was in part about rejecting
this idea and affirming its opposite, namely, that it is citizens who own
the wealth, privately, and have the right to hold it, trade it, or give it
way as they choose. Taxation is merely a payment for government’s
services, such as providing the defense of the country, its court system,
its police force and the like. Everything else is private property.

Professor Sunstein, an arguably likely choice of President Obama for the
U. S. Supreme Court, wants to take American back to pre-revolutionary days
and affirm that it is government, not the citizens, that owns property. He
joins, thus, Karl Marx and Frederick Engels who in The Communist Manifesto
declared as the first job on the road to the essentially
reactionary–rather than progressive–system of communism the abolition of
private property.

Of course, Professor Sunstein and others who hold this position and have
published prominent works advancing their case, do have arguments that
need to be addressed. I am here not debating whether they are right or
wrong, although I do think their position is impossible to sustain
philosophically, ethically, or politically. For now, however, my aim is to
make it clear to my readers that President Obama’s objective is indeed a
radical change in how American is to be governed. He seems to embrace at
least one of the basic tenets of socialism and communism, namely, that all
property must be public and controlled by the government.

We are in for some serious changes indeed.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s