Column #1 on Obama’s Speech

The Celebrated vs. The Obscure

Tibor R. Machan

It bothered me a bit when President Obama said, in his inaugural address,
that “it has been the risk-takers, the doers, the makers of things—some
celebrated but more often men and women obscure in their labor, who have
carried us up the long, rugged path towards prosperity and freedom”
because, well, I am not sure how broad his categories are. After all, I
am a doer of sorts, as I produce books, teach my students, write my
columns, organize my conferences and so forth. But perhaps these don’t
qualify as “doing” something. Do they involve taking risks? Sure—in the
career of most writers, both fiction and non-fiction, much time is spent
on crafting sentences, paragraphs, and chapters with no assurance that
anyone will read these, that they will see the light of day in a
publication, that reviewers—assuming there will be any—will have the
slightest appreciation for what one has labored to produce. The teaching
people like me do is also rather risky since all that work, albeit usually
paid for, may simply be ignored by one’s students, the subjects covered
merely skimmed if even that. Once again, one risks wasting one’s energy,
intelligence, learning on doing what will not be appreciated very much at
all.

And what about those conferences we produce? Sure, they will be attended
by some people but then what? Who knows if the talent we bring together
reaches anyone in the meager audiences that attend.

But this is not all. What about all those managers who deal with task in
organizations, people whose work consists of making arrangements, who
think mostly rather than “do”? Are these folks included by Mr. Obama?
Are they worthy?

My impression is that the passage I have quoted above from our new
president continues the misimpression that the worthy kind of work must be
physical labor. No doubt, such work is worthwhile. Nonetheless the work
done by entrepreneurs and inventors and architects, work that’s largely
intellectual and not so physical must not be overlooked.

Of course, very few of us have their work celebrated other than by a few
family members, friends and perhaps some colleagues. Which is one reason
that most parents wish for their children to find work that is satisfying
quite apart from being celebrated, even well paid. When they day is done,
such work will probably escape the attention of most people, certainly
those in the media who might make it prominent, who could promote it to a
celebratory status, as that happens with movie actors, famous painters,
musicians, and others who manage to catch the public’s attention.

Most of us are indeed hardly celebrated but surely that’s not very
significant because if we do work that is compensated, worthwhile,
productive, creative, inventive and shows a bit of flare, that’s reward
enough unless we suffer from an obsessive need to be appreciated by other
people. No doubt there are such people and sometimes their need can lead
them to be crowd pleasers, which can involve doing some valuable things.
But there isn’t all that much room “at the top.” If we all had to get to
such a position before we could gain self-respect, most societies would
suffer from much malaise. Instead we are best off having the conviction
that what we do is a good thing whether it is widely hailed, whether it is
announced to the world. And fortunately many of us are able to gain such
self-esteem independently of pleasing too many others apart from some
intimates.

President Obama’s efforts to curry favor with the unappreciated,
uncelebrated masses does not, for me, ring true. In any case, I would
hope that it is not much needed by Americans who work at significant jobs,
be these mostly physical or, instead, intellectual. One can only hope
that quite without what the likes of President Obama wish to do for them
they are happy with their lot. Indeed, for the President of the United
States of America it is really somewhat out of line to make it appear that
what most of us need is for him to show us his care. It is far more
important, I would suggest, to gain the care and love and appreciation of
those who know us well, not only as anonymous members of the working
masses.

Machan holds the R. C. Hoiles Chair in business ethics and free enterprise
at Chapman University, Orange, CA. His collection of columns (unproofed)
may be found at http://tiborrmachan.blogspot.com/

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s