Column on Clintons and the Race Card

Do the Clintons Deploy the Race Card?

Tibor R. Machan

Elections do not interest me a great deal. Not because they cannot ever be
important but because my own focus is on political principles, not
personalities or emotional hot buttons. Moreover, these days no one
running for anything articulates truly sound ideas on political economy.
Among the candidates for president only Ron Paul, whose chances of winning
the Republican nomination are practically nil, shows interest in the
principles of the free society and even his message has been recast so
that now his ads on California radio stations, for example, make him sound
like one of the Pat Buchanan nationalists who is concerned mainly with
illegal aliens.)

The notion that one must vote for someone, anyone, just to vote, never
mind that everyone running advocates bad ideas, bad policies, is
completely off the wall. That really amounts to throwing away one’s
vote–a kind of electoral littering. Better to wait for a time when
perhaps some sensible people, with sensible ideas, become candidates.

Nonetheless, sometimes when a candidate has no concern for sound
principles but only for winning elections, the lack of a political vision
becomes significant. For example, one of my neighbors who works for a
community college has a sign up advocating that we all vote for a measure
that would deliver additional funds to the college district. There seems
to be no other political agenda on this neighbor’s mind but one that
amounts to ripping off others so as to gain benefits.

Anyway, lack of political principles can easily lead a candidate to stress
other types of generalities, such as racial sentiments. Hillary and,
especially, Bill Clinton appear to be in this fix now, trying to find some
general issues apart from basic political ideas that will attract voters.
Lacking any unifying idea of what this country is about–freedom,
equality, order, spirituality, whatever–it seems like the Clintons are
now putting their money on broad racial or sexual sentiments. Because
Barack Obama is black, they can invoke, as Bill Clinton has done recently
in South Carolina, the names of discredited or scary black leaders like
Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton, thus linking the Senator with these men’s
one-sided leadership, the kind that folks with racial bias will certainly
be alarmed by.

Because of this the Clintons have recently become targets of the criticism
of some liberal democrats who do not want their party to return to the era
when it got all too comfortably in bed with racists. Even as a mere,
pragmatic tactic this approach no longer carries any punch. The bulk of
Americans, as Obama said after his South Carolina victory, just don’t much
care now about the race of the candidates.

But then where else are the Clintons–who do not advance any kind of
coherent system of ideas (perhaps because the one they may well have,
namely Hillary’s “it takes a village” socialism, is too offensive to
mention)–going to find common ground with enough voters, apart from
forging a community with people who are prejudiced? Without an idea or
vision of what kind of political system they are going to support when in
office, the only thing they seem to be able to offer now, in a crunch, is
that they, unlike their black opponent, will not favor only blacks. This
even though Senator Obama has been rather careful to distance himself from
any notion of black solidarity as his strategy for winning races.

One can unite voters on the basis of several common factors. One, the
right sort, is a political vision. Another, an insidious one, is racial
prejudice or apprehension. Another objectionable one is class hatred.

In South Carolina this last had no foundation at all. Indeed, class
divisions are a phony device for separating Americans, even though many
politicians give it a try. (What upsets people about class is when people
are deemed to have been born into it, as a matter of a birthright. Merely
being richer than others doesn’t cut it since riches can fast disappear
and wealth can be earned and, in any case, most people want to become

I doubt, by the way, that too many in the Clinton camp are out and out
racists. But I do think that out of desperation, and in the absence of a
coherent political philosophy, many will at least be tempted to invoke the
race card–subtly but still!

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s